A 41-year-old woman shot in her van on a California beach in 1983 remained unsolved for 42 years until detectives used DNA and genealogy to identify two suspects—one with a violent history of armed attacks. But unresolved questions linger about who pulled the trigger and whether a third person was involved. DNA evidence preserved for 40 years, combined with genealogical databases, allowed detectives to identify Charlie Sneed and Stephen Hardy as suspects decades after Toby's murder in 1983.