A 30-year-old Arizona woman found floating naked and face-down in a nature preserve pond in 2016 sparks a decade-long mystery as police mishandle evidence and media coverage masks a potential crime. Missing belongings, shoe prints, a latex glove, and undetermined autopsy findings suggest foul play, yet investigators pivot toward suicide narrative and focus narrowly on the separated husband while overlooking critical leads and redacted evidence. Alyssa's deeply religious lifestyle and documented opposition to suicide based on her faith make a self-harm conclusion inconsistent with accounts from family, friends, and church members who described her as stable and planning future events.