Regina Hicks, a 25-year-old Ohio mother, was found dead in her submerged car in 2001—a case ruled undetermined for decades. Keith Morrison and producer Tim Uehlinger reveal how a bizarre arson scheme involving a custom-made face mask and a reluctant witness who broke his silence after 24 years finally brought her killer to justice. Small-town murders create tighter emotional bonds within communities, causing trauma that lasts generations and informs victims' families' lives permanently.