Dee Warner vanished from her Michigan farm in April 2021; her husband Dale was arrested in 2023 without her body being found. Investigators discovered her remains preserved in a fertilizer tank he had moved across the property, leading to his conviction on second-degree murder charges. Josh Mankiewicz and Andrea Canning discuss how they both covered this case, the psychological profile that predicted she was on the property, and an eerie psychic reading that accurately described the alleged crime scene before evidence confirmed the details. Dale Warner's plan to hide his wife's body in a fertilizer tank nearly worked because he used misdirection about dangerous chemicals to discourage searches, keeping investigators away from the tank for years.