In April 2020, a beloved cyclist was found dead in an Indiana ditch, and his widow Katrina Fouts was accused of plotting to poison him with toxic mushrooms. When the poison failed, her accomplice—a retired police officer—strangled the victim instead. Josh Mankiewicz and reporter Blayne Alexander discuss the bizarre murder case, the investigation that saw through Katrina's manipulative interviews, and why a jury acquitted her of murder but convicted her of conspiracy. People in abusive or dangerous relationships often ignore clear warning signs because they fear being alone more than they fear harm, even when they have financial resources to leave safely.